The Reader: Book vs. Movie

































My friend and I are having arguments over this point, so I'll be interested to hear other thoughts, but I contend that Hannah's character in the novel is far more largely nuanced and sympathetic than Kate Winslet's interpretation in the movie. Let me clarify, though, because I do not mean to imply that Kate Winslet's character is not nuanced or, in any way, unsympathetic. Her portrayal is just more nuanced and sympathetic in a smaller way.

For those of you who have NOT read the book or seen the movie, stop reading now. Plot spoilers ahead.

Schlink's pathos-filled novel The Reader follows Micheal Berg through his first serious romance and then contemplates the aftermath, as Micheal is forever changed by his interaction with Hannah. Hannah is beautiful, pensive, and obsessed with stories. It is not until later that we find out why she is so moved by fiction. The relationship between Micheal and Hannah is - some could argue - Lolita reversed: Hannah is 35 and Micheal is 15 and Hannah (presumably) realizes what she does to him. This 'presumably' in my opinion is where the major divergence between book and film resides.

First the book. Michael falls deeply in love with Hannah and because he is the narrator this makes sense to us. Hannah does not appear to us as a monster because Micheal does not see her as one. She is complicated, confusing, loving, demanding, and needy, but never - fully - monstrous. Our own interpolation of abuse, our own analysis of the inappropriate nature of this relationship introduces the monstrousness; Micheal, however, sees only the woman of his dreams. The fact that she functionally ruins him and his ability to exist in a healthy (age appropriate) relationship ever again still does not convince him that she has victimized him. It is only at the end when the Jewish woman ponders that Hannah has abused him that this idea is introduced to - and contemplated by - Micheal. Until then, he is deeply in love with the woman of his dreams. Even when she stands on trial and understands what she's done, he loves her.

The novel also allows the interpretation that she loves him, too. This is a critical interpretative point because it enables the readers to view Hannah as capable of love. I do not believe this is completely possible in the movie. In the novel, when Hannah slaps him, bloodies his lip, and then falls into his arms, crying, and then finally surrendering to him, she allows him to shelter her, to take care of her. It seems that she needs him to protect her, which could lead to love. Also, when Hannah comes to the pool, presumably, to say goodbye to Michael or, at least, to see him one final time, it is suggested that she cares for him. If she did not, she would just leave. Neither of these scenes are present in the movie, much to its detriment.

In the movie version, Kate Winslet provides a masterful performance, and if she doesn't win the Oscar, there are other things at play. She is immensely and completely Hannah in this sad, emotive version of the novel. Immediately, we are given more interpretative space in the movie - closed to us in the novel - because although Micheal is central, he is not the narrator. Hannah's actions stand alone without a filter. Though there are moments when she does seem to take pity on him - when she helps after he's sick or when she stiffly agrees that she loves him - the majority of their interaction appears to be between a love sick school boy and a conniving older woman, out for her own pleasure. They have sex a lot, but Hannah never exhibits a thoughtful caress; she is never sweet to him. In short, she's mean. When he spontaneously kisses her in front of the waitress at the outdoor cafe, she seems surprised and perhaps embarassed, but not in love. When she cries and laughs in the church as she listens to the children sing (we realize later that she must be imagining the women the church who burned to death because she refused to open the door) her laughter and tears suggests that she understands the unfairness, the beauty, and the vicissitudes of life. However, there is no suggestion that she attributes these feelings to Michael. Towards him, she remains unattached.

At the end of the movie, when Hannah and Michael meet after years of separation, she seems happy to see him and her eyes, finally, have a softness about them. When Michael shunts the opportunity to talk about their affair, her face clamps closed again and the years of defensive posturing move back in place. Even now, she cannot admit her deep feelings for him - if they ever existed. Perhaps she is embarassed about the way she looks or about their relationship or, perhaps, she realizes what she has lost and can never reclaim. (This final possibility would help to explain her sudden suicide, an act that keeps her away from Michael - but in the realm of his loving imagination - forever.)

In the end, perhaps it's not important that Hannah loved him. Perhaps the point is that Hannah, because of the vile atrocities she committed, is incapable of loving. If this is true, it makes Michael's life even more sad. Perhaps I'm being too sympathetic, too much of a romantic, to look for an ability to love in Hannah, but I don't do it for Hannah's sake. Her monstrousness or a victim-status is, perhaps, not ultimately the point. I am most concerned with Michael's selfless love that he carries with him his entire life for a woman who may or may not be worth the attention. The notion that she loved him back, in my mind justifies Michael's life-long sacrifice. As with most, great literature, it is open for interpretation, which is why, ultimately, I prefer this book over the movie. Kate Winslet's portrayal of Hannah is brilliant but she is a brilliant monster who feels very sorry for herself, and an illiterate woman victimized by her own pride and situation, but not a woman who loves. For Michael, this is a tragedy.


The novel contemplates a number of other provocative ideas that the movie also touches upon: how far does Nazi culpability go in German society? Is Michael guilty for Hannah's atrocities because he loved her? How much should subsequent German generations take responsibility for the transgressions of their parents? And finally: Can one right action in a life (or a mostly honest life) absolve a person of one atrocious act? At the end of the tale, Hannah learns to read, and as she says when Michael asks her what she has learned in her life, she answers that she has learned to read. To Hannah, this appears to be enough; but perhaps the humanistically expansive nature of reading has enabled her to understand her sins. In this way, this small statement may mean much more. For someone who loved stories and their enveloping, therapeutic nature, perhaps this was a type of redemption.

In my view, whether Hannah loved Michael is the hinge-pin of her character - not that she learned to read. Hannah effectively killed 300 people. A person like this may not be able to love another human being; in fact, they may willingly resist this. It must be better to stay away from everyone after committing a horrific act like that; falling in love, learning to empathize, would raise too many questions about the potential lives and loves of the people you killed. Best to stay aloof. Hannah in the movie DOES stay aloof and she is depraved and monstrous because of it; however, Hannah in the novel falls in love, if only a little, with the boy who loves her so completely he lives his entire life for her. Doesn't this small act of kindness at least make her human?

Comments

  1. I liked your analysis. You provide some good contrast & comparisons between the novel & the movie.

    However, the only part I feel miffed by is that you leave no ambiguity for the fact that Hannah never the "order/report" that she uncannily admitted in the trial.

    Thus, it seems like your automatically assume she is "monstrous" since she was the main person responsible for killing 300 lives in the church.

    My questions are this:
    - If we assume that she didn't write that "order/report," doesn't she deserve more sympathy?

    - Going along that previous assumption, why did she admit to something she didn't do? Was it because she was more terrified she didn't want anyone to know of her illiteracy? If so, what does this say about Hannah? Was it her vanity that got the best out of her?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. INDEED DR SAYO HERBAL HEALER HAS THE CURE FOR FOLLOWING HERPES VIRUS, HIV/AIDS, CANCER ALL TYPES, DIABETES, HEPATITIS A/B, PAD, ETC......FOR MORE INFORMATION VISIT HIS WEBSITE: sayoherbalhome.com I was once a victim of the herpes virus with many symptoms on my body, I was cured of the virus thanks to the help of Dr Sayo herbal medicine. I saw most of his patient testimonials on blogs and social media pages, cured of various disease/virus and illnesses. I contacted him on his email address to which he replied and asked me a few questions and the preparation method for which I paid, he sent me the herbal medicines and instructions on how to take it I apply the herbal medicine for 4 weeks and the symptoms on my body were healed after taking the herbal medicine treatment, I went for test and my result was negative with know trace of virus in my blood and am completely cured. You can also be cured, contact him on his email:  sayoherbalhealer@gmail.com  or WhatsApp him on +2349012175679 or visit his facebook page: https://www.facebook.com/SayoHerbalHealer

      Delete
  2. what year did the book end?

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hi
    I liked your analysis. You've shed some light on the romance side of things (Hanna's ability to love, and that she loved Michael in her own way etc) that I didn't think of. I was just focusing on Michael's 'obsession' with her. I dislike how other critics state that M was raped by H, he was a willing participant. Of course, not saying their 'relationship' is morally correct, it is dysfunctional and it did mess him up in regards to 'healthy and normal' age-appropriate relationships. I just think that rape is something different altogether.
    It's a complex novel, and I also prefer it to the movie (although the movie was not too awful).
    Anyway, thanks!

    ReplyDelete
  4. This is a testimony that I will tell everyone in the world. i have been married for 4 years and on the fifth year of my marriage, another woman had a spell to take my lover away from me and my husband left me and the kids and we have suffered for 2 years until i meant a post where this man Zuma Zuk have helped someone and i decided to give him a try to help me bring my love Husband home and believe me i just send my picture to him and that of my husband and after 48 hours as he have told me after doing everything he asked me to do, i saw a car drove into the house and behold it was my husband and he have come to me and the kids and that is why i am happy to make everyone of you in similar case to meet with this man and have your marriage fixed His email: spiritualherbalisthealing@gmail.com whatsapp him on this +15068001647..... thank so much Zuma Zuk.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Your decision of web host will impact your webpage more than you might suspect. Your facilitating organization will go about as the establishment for the remainder of your site. Pick a quality facilitating supplier and you'll wind up with a high-performing, secure webpage, that is online when you need it the most.
    https://varundigital23.wixsite.com/my-site/post/bluehost-review-2021

    ReplyDelete
  6. It's very nice of you to share your knowledge through posts. I love to read stories about your experiences. They're very useful and interesting. I am excited to read the next posts. I'm so grateful for all that you've done. Keep plugging. Many viewers like me fancy your writing. Thank you for sharing precious information with us. Get for more information top parenting blogger in India

    ReplyDelete
  7. Good luck to anyone reading this true life story of mine, I Was Diagnosed With type 2 Herpes Virus Last year, And I Was Looking For Solution To Be Cured Luckily I Saw Testimonies On How Dr OYAGU Cure Herpes Virus I Decided To Contact Dr OYAGU I Contacted Him He Prepared A Herbal Medicine Portion And Sent It To Me, I Started The Herbal Medicine For My Health. He Gave Me Step By Step Instructions On How To Apply It, When I Applied It As Instructed, I Was Cured Of This Deadly Herpes Within 2 weeks, I Am Now Herpes Negative. My Brother And Sister I No That There Are So Many People That Have The Same Herpes Virus Please contact Dr OYAGU To Help You Too, And Help Me To Thank Dr OYAGU For Cure Me, I’m Cured By Dr. OYAGU Herbal Medicine, His Contact Email:oyaguherbalhome@gmail.com or visit his website https://oyaguspellcaster.wixsite.com/oyaguherbalhome Or Cell Whatsapp Number +2348101755322 thank you

    ReplyDelete
  8. Hello everyone, sharing this testimony is my greatest happiness also to let every patient know there is cure to get rid of human papillomavirus. I was once a HPV patient for a very long time. I have been taking medications because my doc in Canada told me there is no cure except pills to control it which I have been taking. Until I found a faithful and truthful herbalist who finally cured me with herbal remedy. Everything about the virus was gone, my genital warts I have been trying to remove, they all cleared off. Here is the herbalist information to reach him via : oyaguherbalhome@gmail.com or whatsapp +2348101755322 his website https://oyaguspellcaster.wixsite.com/oyaguherbalhome. Dr Oyagu is great and very kind to every patient. He also Cure 1.HIV/AIDS
    2.HERPES
    3 CANCER of all kind
    4.HSV 1&2
    5.Herpatitis B
    6.Diabetes
    7.HPV

    ReplyDelete
  9. I don't have time beating around the bush, instead I go straight to the point.... So to you doubters I ain't expecting you all to believe my testimony but only the few chosen ones by God. In a short summary, I'm here to tell the whole world that I recently got cured from my long term herpes disease, both the HSV1 and HSV2 through the assistance of Herbalist doctor Oyagu I pray God continually blesses Dr Oyagu in all he does, because he is indeed a very good, nice and powerful doctor. I’m cured of herpes disease at last! Wow I'm so much in great joy because I've never in my life believed herbs works, but meeting doctor Oyagu was an eye opener and he made me believe that herpes truly got a complete cure. I used the doctor's herbal medicine for just two weeks and I was totally cured from both my HSV1 and HSV2. I'm so excited. For help and assistance in getting rid of your herpes virus you can Call/WhatsApp doctor Oyagu on his telephone number: +2348101755322 or for more inquiries you can as well contact the doctor on EMAIL: oyaguherbalhome@gmail.com

    ReplyDelete
  10. Are you battling with any health related issues or infection is not the end of your life, why not contact a herbal practitioner for cure Dr Oyagu has herbal remedies and permanent solution for all your health related problems. recommend him to you today only because i have also used his herbal medicine and it worked perfectly on my health problem, you can actually save yourself from giving your hard earned money to Scammers if only you can contact Dr Oyagu today for genuine and Permanent cure herbal products . Pls help share this post to save yourself and your love ones. Dr Oyagu is specialize in these areas, Permanent herbal supplements for anxiety and depression, HIV/AIDS, Diabetes, Epilepsy, Blood, Cancer, HPV, ALS, herpes etc. Email: oyaguherbalhome@gmail.com or visit his website https://oyaguspellcaster.wixsite.com/oyaguherbalhome Or Cell Whatsapp Number +2348101755322 thank you

    ReplyDelete
  11. DR OYAGU herbal medicine is a good remedy for herpes simplex virus cure. My name is MIGNON WRIGHT , am from USA,I am here to give my testimony about DR OYAGU who helped me in my life, i want to inform the public how i was cured from (HERPES SIMPLEX VIRUS) by DR OYAGU, i visited different hospital but they gave me list of drugs like Familiar, Zovirax, and Valtrex which is very expensive to treat the symptoms and never cured me. I was browsing through the Internet searching for remedy on HERPES and i saw comment of people talking about how DR OYAGU cured them, when i contacted him he gave me hope and send a Herbal medicine to me that i took and it seriously worked for me, am a free person now without any problem, my HERPES result came out negative, I pray to God to never let me and my family forget you in our life, am now cured permanently, you can also get your self cured my friends if you really need this doctor help, you can reach him on his website ;https://oyaguspellcaster.wixsite.com/oyaguherbalhome Email: oyaguherbalhome@gmail.com or via whatsapp +2348101755322

    ReplyDelete
  12. Greatest thanks to Dr Oyagu for his herbal medicine that he prepared for me and when I start using it in just 2weeks I was completely cured and that ended my HERPES SIMPLEX 1&2 DISEASE i am so happy and grateful to Dr Oyagu . after reading about him on a testimony of Jason Cash on a blogger. I knew suddenly Dr Oyagu was the right Doctor to cure my HERPES SIMPLEX 1&2 DISEASE. I discuss with Dr Oyagu and he prepared a herbal medicine for me and when it got sent to me in south Korean . I used the herbal medicine in 2weeks and i went for check up again. after 15years of suffering from HERPES SIMPLEX 1&2 at last i am smiling once again. Dr Oyagu also has remedy to others disease like COLD SORES,HIV/AIDS,DIABETES.CANCER,HIGH BLOOD PRESSURE AND MANY MORE. I oblige everyone to contact this powerful herbalist Dr Oyagu and be free from your suffering. contact his WhatsApp line: +2348101755322 or visit his Website https://oyaguspellcaster.wixsite.com/oyaguherbalhome Email:Oyaguherbalhome@gmail.com

    ReplyDelete
  13. INDEED DR SAYO HERBAL HEALER HAS THE CURE FOR FOLLOWING HERPES VIRUS, HIV/AIDS, CANCER ALL TYPES, DIABETES, HEPATITIS A/B, PAD, ETC......FOR MORE INFORMATION VISIT HIS WEBSITE: sayoherbalhome.com I was once a victim of the herpes virus with many symptoms on my body, I was cured of the virus thanks to the help of Dr Sayo herbal medicine. I saw most of his patient testimonials on blogs and social media pages, cured of various disease/virus and illnesses. I contacted him on his email address to which he replied and asked me a few questions and the preparation method for which I paid, he sent me the herbal medicines and instructions on how to take it I apply the herbal medicine for 4 weeks and the symptoms on my body were healed after taking the herbal medicine treatment, I went for test and my result was negative with know trace of virus in my blood and am completely cured. You can also be cured, contact him on his email:  sayoherbalhealer@gmail.com  or WhatsApp him on +2349012175679 or visit his facebook page: https://www.facebook.com/SayoHerbalHealer

    ReplyDelete
  14. Ivermectin 12 mg is the oral medication that is taken by patients for curing the parasitic infections in the body. After Review: Side Effects, Dosage, Use, How To Work ✈Available In USA, Uk, China With Fast Delivery ☆ 30% Off ✭Shop Now ✔Trustable ♥secure

    ReplyDelete
  15. Fildena 100 Mg brings in the much-needed generic solution to the excessively Best generic Viagra for treating erectile dysfunction (ED) in men. The medication infuses typical active ingredient Sildenafil. Get purple pills from reliablekart order now.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Phontinent Technologies is leading React Native App Development Company. We serve react native development services for mobile and web applications.

    Visit us:- react native for mobile

    ReplyDelete
  17. Lineup dubaiLineup.ae is Social sports app building communities for all sports helping people connect, stay fit, network and play sports together.

    ReplyDelete
  18. Play online roulette for real money in india with golden444.com and more interesting online games like cricket, Football, Teenpatti, rummy, Ludo. Play now

    Visit us:- https://golden444.com

    ReplyDelete
  19. Kan Universal is one of the top LED video wall manufacturers in India offering LED display screen for advertising, LED light module and digital signage screens.

    ReplyDelete
  20. Buy Ivermectin 6mg for Humans is an anti-parasite medication. Ivermectin is used to treat infections in the body that are caused by certain parasites

    ReplyDelete
  21. We are a local vehicle rental company who provides commercial vehicles and van on rental basis. Call us today 01953 665 421 to latest prices. Visit us now

    Visit us:- daily rental van

    ReplyDelete
  22. Take5music.in is an online music learning platform where you can get online classes of traditional instruments. Book your class now for piano, tabla and more.

    ReplyDelete
  23. JS Asphalt is a friendly family run business, the owner John Smith started out in the business over 35 years ago with his Father Levi Smith, John later took on the business and with his wealth of experience and hands on approach has continued to run it with the original work ethic he and his father set up, while keeping up to date with the ever-growing demands of their services.
    Visit Us :- Car Park Repairs

    ReplyDelete
  24. LCV Centre is a fully approved main dealership for Maxus Commercial Vehicles , operating in the Norfolk, Suffolk and Cambridgeshire areas.
    We offer sales, service, parts and repairs for the whole Maxus range of vehicles. Our success is measured by the desire to provide unrivalled customer service across our business, with a clear understanding of our customer’s requirements and needs.

    ReplyDelete
  25. Best software development company. We provide custom development services for Webapplication, Website, Mobile App and Business software development.

    web application development company dubai

    dubai web application development

    ReplyDelete
  26. Fortune Family erläutert wichtige Standpunkte und Ansätze zum Thema Coaching. Warum dieses Jahr 2021 so wichtig ist, berichtet die Erfolgsfamily hier...Fortune Family Erfahrung

    ReplyDelete
  27. S142BRNN924, Photoelectric Amplifier 1CH 2NPN SPDT TIMER, μ-Processor controlled, Rated operational voltage: 24 VAC/DC, 24 VAC, 115 VAC or 230 VAC, CARLO-GAVAZZI

    ReplyDelete
  28. PDFSeva provides online Free Download PDF File Library For Pdf eBooks, Study Materials, Useful Notes, Government Schemes Forms, Application, Banking and Education Related PDF File Collection.

    ReplyDelete
  29. Buy Women's Wear Online. Radhella provides a wide range of Western wear dresses, products with High-quality materials, Attractive colors, Trendy designs and Great High discounts.
    https://radhella.com/

    ReplyDelete
  30. Zongaroo.com is a premium online magazine covering technology, business, entertainment and lifestyle. It has high quality articles on topics relevant to young people of India.
    Online magazine

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular Posts